Writer's Guild

Well, let's all try this, then.

The Writer's Guild is a vehicle for promoting both the quality and the quanitity of stories by means of useful feedback. You DO NOT have to post a review for every story - no deadlines, no schedules (same for stories). Being a member of the Guild means that when you give criticism, it must follow the rules outlined below. As a member, criticism must be accepted as being made in good faith.

To join the Writer's Guild, you must meet these criteria:

1) Eligible for membership here at BI.org
2) Must have an inflation story posted somewhere - preferably here.
3) Must be willing to give and accept constructive criticism.
4) Criticism given must be without malice and be accepted with this knowledge.
5) Must be committed to improving the overall state of Inflation, uh, Literature (*ahem*)

Review Format:

(Review)

Written review, explaining the reasons for your scoring below. Give examples if possible.

(Scorecard)

Technical

Spelling - 0-100%
Grammer - 0-100%
Sentence Structure - 0-100%

Artistic
Subject - 0-100%
Plot - 0-100%
Originality - 0-100%
Character Development 0-100%

To offer a story for review, post it to the Feedback Forum as per Luther's example, but add "Writer's Guild: " to the beginning of the title. If you are not a member of the Guild, we ask that you please refrain from responding to the post. Those not following the rules will be called on it. Please refrain from chatting with each other from within the reviews - save that for the Writer's Den.

deleted_20091014

I'll join up as soon as I get round to writing a new story.

darth_clone19
darth_clone19's picture

Question: The few inflation stuff Ive done has been chapters in "choose your own path" transformation/expansion stories. Does that count as having an inflation story posted somewhere?

 -   Read my stories: darth-clone19.deviantart.com 

Fukureru-Shogun

I'll join. I hope this incourages me to pick up my writing..

Inflate123
Inflate123's picture

Hey, have any stories been submitted to this? I have been approached personally by an author who just wants some direct feedback so I'm going to do that, but...I like this idea and want to see it supported. Is everybody just not writing right now, with school and the impending holidays?

SvenS
SvenS's picture

A couple have been submitted, Inflate123, but only one or two replies so far. I've been meaning to - honest! - just no time. I think I should be able to get back into my projects soon, so I should have something, as well. I have been practicing critiquing skills for another author who has graciously allowed me to so. As soon as I can, I'll be participating again.

Fukureru-Shogun

Good god, I spelled "encourages" wrong in my last post. Maybe I shouldn't join...

Anyway, I've been an a looooong slump. I'm not sure what its gonna take to motivate me.

dragon_6860
dragon_6860's picture

heh, well, i don't know about anyone else, but Iv'e notices that the guild page has been kinda dead, with reviews of stories, there are quite a few stories, but i think the only people who've written a review have been myself and Rodger64, heh, it can be a bit of a downer when you get no responce, postive or negitive, but eh :) That's just me, I try to always review the new stories.

No, I would not want to live in a world without dragons, as I would not want to live in a world without magic, for that is a world without mystery, and that is a world without faith.

darth_clone19
darth_clone19's picture
Fukureru-Shogun wrote:
Good god, I spelled "encourages" wrong in my last post. Maybe I shouldn't join...

Anyway, I've been an a looooong slump. I'm not sure what its gonna take to motivate me.

I dont write, and even I have seen plenty to inspire me lately, lol. Of course, its inspiration gone to waste, but I dont know how to transfer excess inspiration to another person.

 -   Read my stories: darth-clone19.deviantart.com