Which inflation game would you prefer?

with game mechanics
54% (13 votes)
without game mechanics
46% (11 votes)
Total votes: 24
Lopni

Hi all! It's yet another "video game about inflation" question, but now - from a game mechanics point of view.


1. With game mechanics

Such games have a cosy booky tabletop feel, because they are based on a tabletop

Ability scores are measured in points (Strength 15, Dexterity 16, whatever it means), characters move by this number of cells per round

For example, if a character jumps from a window of a castle and lands into the saddle of her horse in order to gallop away - she'll fall by 10 feet per round and take 1d6 damage. If she would inflate, she would take 1d6 gallons per round and stretch by 1 foot per turn


2. Without game mechanics

Such games are easier to make and to play, they have a realistic feel

Ability scores are athletic measurements (Capacity 500 gallons, Speed 10 mph), characters move according to real physics, in yards or metres per second

For example, character's jump from a window of a castle looks like in real life because it's resolved by flight dynamics. Character's inflation looks like filling a balloon in real life because it's resolved by dynamics of thin shell

firnov
firnov's picture

I go for option 2. I like fantasy, but my "inflation world" is more realism based. It makes it more thrilling that it really can happen.

A real life game like this can be a lot of fun. I wonder who the characters can be.

And boom goes the inflatee

Lopni

me too! ^_^ and i also think it's within Nature's laws so why hassle of inventing a game mechanics when Newton's mechanics is already there ^_^ if you want it short and simple F = m a is three letters, you can't beat that ^_^

preferences divided 50-50 might mean tabletop lovers are also for fantasy realism, but with gaming session feel preserved

Margeret Moonlught
Margeret Moonlught's picture

an H-Game or a visual novel might be the way you want to go with this. 

BI.org’s very own metamorphic incomprehensible memetic fractal entity 

Lopni

hahaha drawing the third visual novel is the last thing i want. but thanks! the question is more about any inflation games in general